Read With BookClubbish May 2021 Pick: The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner

If you haven’t had the chance to read the book that everyone’s been talking about, read along with us! The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner hit the New York Times bestseller list when it first dropped in March and we’ve been hooked ever since. Take historical fiction, add a little bit of spice (read: suspense), and you’ve got your next favorite book.


And, as always, don’t forget to join in on the conversation all month long on social by using the hashtag #ReadWithBookClubbish.

May 2021 Read With BookClubbish Pick: The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner

The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner


“A bold, edgy, accomplished debut!” —Kate Quinn, New York Times bestselling author of The Alice Network and The Huntress

A forgotten history. A secret network of women. A legacy of poison and revenge. Welcome to The Lost Apothecary…

Hidden in the depths of eighteenth-century London, a secret apothecary shop caters to an unusual kind of clientele. Women across the city whisper of a mysterious figure named Nella who sells well-disguised poisons to use against the oppressive men in their lives. But the apothecary’s fate is jeopardized when her newest patron, a precocious twelve-year-old, makes a fatal mistake, sparking a string of consequences that echo through the centuries.

Meanwhile in present-day London, aspiring historian Caroline Parcewell spends her tenth wedding anniversary alone, running from her own demons. When she stumbles upon a clue to the unsolved apothecary murders that haunted London two hundred years ago, her life collides with the apothecary’s in a stunning twist of fate—and not everyone will survive.

With crackling suspense, unforgettable characters and searing insight, The Lost Apothecary is a subversive and intoxicating debut novel of secrets, vengeance and the remarkable ways women can save each other despite the barrier of time.

Pick up your copy at:

Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Google Play | Kobo | Apple Books | Indiebound | Indigo | Audible | Goodreads

Discussion Questions

Spoiler alert! Read at your own risk.

  1. The Lost Apothecary opens with Nella in her shop, preparing to
    dispense a poison meant to kill a man. Her work is sinister, and much
    about her character is dark and disturbing. When you first learned that Nella was a murderer, how did you view her? How did your feelings change over the course of the book as more of her past was revealed? Did you believe she would eventually find redemption? In the end, did you see her as a hero, a villain, or something in between? Why?
  2. At the beginning of Caroline’s story, she finds the apothecary vial while on a mudlarking tour. Had you heard of mudlarking prior to reading this book? Do you believe that fate or coincidence led to her discovery? Have you ever stumbled on something that you consider to be fate?
  3. Both Nella and Caroline have been betrayed by men in their lives. In what ways did the two women respond similarly to these betrayals? In what ways did they respond differently? Do you feel that one woman was more emotionally resilient than the other?
  4. Nella and Eliza form an unlikely friendship early in the story, despite Nella’s resistance to having the young girl in her shop a second time. Why do you think Nella eventually softened her heart toward Eliza? What drew the two characters—one on the cusp of womanhood, the other toward the end of her life—toward one another? What kind of impact did Eliza have on Nella’s character?
  5. The Lost Apothecary is sprinkled with mention of magick, and several events occur that could be considered either the work of magick or merely good luck. When you learned that Eliza survived after ingesting the Tincture to Reverse Bad Fortune, did you believe it the result of magick, or do you think she was a lucky survivor after jumping into the freezing river?
  6. When James feels a cold coming on, Caroline points him to the eucalyptus oil in the hotel bathroom (p. 195) but she doesn’t tell him it’s for topical use only. Later, we learn that he ingested the toxic oil. While reading, did you consider the possibility that Caroline purposely didn’t tell him the oil was for topical use only? Do you think that, even subconsciously, this might have been a form of revenge?
  7. James is a nuanced character. At different junctures in the story, he shows remorse and heartbreak, only to later lie again to his wife. What did you think of their relationship? Did you believe he was truly sorry for his infidelity, or were his apologies to Caroline yet another form of manipulation?
  8. At the end of the story, when Eliza is an adult with children of her own, she says that Nella still counsels her to “this very day” (p. 300). Do you interpret this as Nella having lived many more years, or is Eliza referring to Nella’s spirit? Why do you think the author might have left this purposefully vague?
  9. While alone in London, Caroline begins to consider how very different her life might have been if she’d not remained in the States with James. As you read about her unfulfilled dreams, did you find yourself thinking about how your life might look today if you’d chosen a different path long ago? What aspirations did you used to have that you might someday like to revisit or pursue?
  10. The Lost Apothecary explores the idea of female empowerment and rebelling against a man’s world. In what ways did Nella, Eliza and Caroline empower themselves? Do you consider The Lost Apothecary a feminist book?
  11. Which of the three characters—Nella, Eliza, or Caroline—did you find the most compelling or enjoyable to read? Why?
  12. The theme of motherhood is explored throughout The Lost Apothecary. Nella mourns her inability to have children, and while Caroline begins the story wishing she had a baby, this changes by the end of her narrative. What wisdom do you think Nella would impart to Caroline about the pursuit of motherhood, if the two women had the opportunity to sit down and talk?
  13. In the historical note, the author states that “in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the largest population of accused poisoners consisted of mothers, wives, and female servants.” Did this statistic surprise you? Given that the science of toxicology didn’t yet exist in the late 18th century, do you think it’s possible that a shop like Nella’s might have actually existed? Which of the many potions and poisonous concoctions did you find the most interesting or surprising?
  14. The Lost Apothecary is paced purposefully so that the truth about Nella’s fate is slowly revealed over the course of the story. What techniques or literary devices did the author use to “drip-feed” this information and maintain the book’s suspense?
  15. Discuss the meaning of the title, The Lost Apothecary. In your opinion, which character is the real “lost apothecary”?

You May Also Like…

Do you have a question you’d like to ask Sarah Penner? Let us know in the comments below!

4 thoughts on “Read With BookClubbish May 2021 Pick: The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner

    1. This is an interesting take! We’ll see if we can squeeze in this question!

    2. I’m not sure if Eliza killed Tom Pepper. In recalling the day they first met at the book shop, Tom had told Eliza how his mother was able to save his life when he was born, as she had brewed a magic potion that put air in his lungs. However, he suspected when magic was granted, it also had an unpredictable price: Tom’s mother died shortly after his birth. We know Eliza brewed her good fortune magic elixir, and poured it into two vials: one pink and one blue. It seemed to work for her, as it appears she impossibly survived her fall. If was left vague as to whether it worked for Nella, but I suspect it did. I did wonder if there was a magical cost to the elixir working. Given that the brew granted good fortune, magic’s side effect of “taking away something” may have been postponed till the elixir wore off… and 10 years later we find Eliza with twins: one girl, one boy.. I feel their existence is reminiscent of the pink and blue vials having worked… that Eliza’s improved fortune led her and Tom to a successful, full, and happy life. However, when the elixir’s effect finally waned, perhaps magic finally extracted its rebound “take away” effect, and Tom developed lung problems.. the magic that once brought him to life ran out for him. With his life having been made possible by magic, there may have been very little Eliza could have done to nurse him back to health. Rather, all she may have been able to do was palliative in nature. Having become well-versed with the magic business through their shop and practice, the Peppers may have seen this coming well in advance.. Tom having perhaps expected the risks of Eliza having used magic in a desperate situation. The little family may have been prepared for all the darker possibilities, and Eliza’s ability to celebrate Tom’s life among all those who loved him seems to indicate this to me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *